Critique Of A Literature Review Essay - 807 Words

Assignment 1: Critique of a Literature Review The article, â€Å"Evaluation of the Dogs, Physical Activity, and Walking (Dogs PAW) Intervention†, by Richards, E., Ogata, N., Cheng, C. aim to conduct a longer-term evaluation of the ability of the Dogs, Physical Activity, and Walking (Dogs PAW) intervention to increase dog walking among dog owners. The research problem being addressed explores maintenance of physical activity (PA) behaviour change postintervention and whether changes in behavioral theoretical constructs mediated changes in dog walking behaviour. The literature review is appropriately positioned in the research report and provides support for same. The first few paragraphs of the article discusses the relationship between†¦show more content†¦Under theoretical framework, the literature review explains a good amount on SCT and PA, however, it is lacking in how it relates in particular to dog walking. It is not until the next paragraph that the authors me ntion the relationship between pet walking and specifically pet attachment to be relating to health outcomes that can be measureable such as blood pressure, triglyceride and cholesterol levels. Upon a review of the authors’ sources, I have identified that a majority consisted of primary sources. One of the sources cited, Albert Bandura, provides a good deal of credibility in conjunction with several medical journals such as the Journal of Physical Activity Health and Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. Many of the sources are extremely relevant to the topic being discussed which in turn provides the reader with pertinent information. One of the other sources which is from Centers of Disease Control and Prevention backs up this article with data pertaining to body mass index calculation and interpretation and information that defines over-weight and obesity. A brief review of the sources identifies a good mix that compliments the article as a whole. After careful con sideration, I have decided that this article is somewhat biased. The purpose is to increase dog walking among dog owners. The target audience is for those who owns dogs; however, individuals with different pets, such as exotic animals like a capybara are excluded. On theShow MoreRelatedReflection Assessment Of Final Draft Points1273 Words   |  6 Pagesreflection of your work. Please do the following: 1. Review Rubric Below 2. Highlight with color highlighter (In MS-WORD or word processor software) if in online class - or circle with color highlighter/pen (something that easy to visually assess quickly) your estimated level of work if in face-to-face class. 3. One level of criteria (either 60%, 70%, 80% or 100%) should be highlighted/circled for each evaluation criteria (Introduction, Literature Review, Theoretical Perspective, Discussion, OrganizationRead MoreThe As A Science For Emancipation871 Words   |  4 Pageswithin the Soviet bloc; it was the theoretical basis for several popular uprisings and revolutionary movements; it was the subject of several political and academic debates; and it was the basis for hundreds of books, dissertations and essays. The projected essay is based on two separate problematic within Marxism: the base-superstructure (foundation-superstructure) metaphor (or the economy as a last instance determining factor) and the integration of an adequate comprehension of the specific oppressionsRead MoreReview Of The Better Angels Of Our Nature By Steven Pinker1262 Words   |  6 PagesINTP 371 - Short Essay Sally Togher | 15 April 2017 | Question 2 —————————- Evaluate and critique the different arguments for the decline in warfare since 1990. In the last decade, discussion of â€Å"the decline of war† has dramatically escalated. This essay evaluates and critiques three major arguments for the decline in warfare since 1990, examining the human nature approach of Steven Pinker, the shorter-term factors proposed by John Mueller and the alternative â€Å"New Wars† theory championed by MaryRead MoreGender Subjectivity, By Judith Butler841 Words   |  4 PagesThis book features a collection of Judith Butler’s essays and her primary intention with this collection is to â€Å"focus on the question of what it might mean to undo restrictive normative conceptions of sexual and gendered life† (12). These essays look at the construction of gender and the way certain conceptions of it are normalized and reproduced in potentially harmful and limiting ways. Butler uses a feminist poststructural framework to critique the normalizing/marginalizing views of gender thatRead More My Development as a Writer Essays 1352 Words   |  6 Pages My English Literature major has helped me to achieve an outstanding level of appreciation, enjoyment, and knowledge of both American and British Literature. As a high school AP English student, I struggled through great works like Hamlet and To the Lighthouse. My teacher’s daily lectures (there was no such thing as class discussion) taught me merely to interpret the works as critics had in the past. I did not enjoy the reading or writing process. As a freshman at Loras, I was enrolled in theRead MoreEdgar Allan. Poe and H. L. Mencken’s Uses of Humor in Negative Reviews1120 Words   |  5 PagesBoth Edgar Allan Poe and H. L. Mencken can write reviews bursting at the seams with sarcasm and humor. These pieces of criticism speak novels about their judgment of these works that don’t â€Å"make the cut† of perceived greatness, and of the types of people who would indulge themselves with them. However, Noà «l Carrol does not speak about the use of humor in arts criticism, for good or for bad. If we are to use Carrol’s definition of arts criticism, then we can’t judge the effectiveness of Poe and Mencken’sRead MoreCritical Examination of Brooks The Formalist Critics1015 Words   |  5 PagesBrooks starts his essay by listing â€Å"articles of faith I could subscribe to† (Brooks 19) and pointing out statements about literary criticism that might go with a formalist criticism. Yet, he questions that list its end, and seems to complain that his that his writings have been largely misunderstood. What his statements have to do with faith in connection with literature is up to the reader, since in one of his articles he specifically mentions, â€Å"literature is not a surrogate for religion† (BrooksRead MoreHenry Fayol1213 Words   |  5 Pagesï » ¿ Assessment - Essay †¨Ã¢â‚¬ ¨Ã¢â‚¬ ¨Assessment (Essay, 2000 words, 30%) is an individual essay. The assignment requires you to use to build an argument that answers the question â€Å"Is Henri Fayol’s management theory relevant today?† †¨Your argument should be presented as an essay. You may however make use of headings to highlight sections of your work†¨Ã¢â‚¬ ¨Your essay should:†¨Ã¢â‚¬ ¨Define the topic: outline what the report is about and how it will be structured i.e. what aspects are you focusing on and why. a. SpecifyRead MoreCritical Criticism Of Huck Finn903 Words   |  4 Pageseducationally required novel for students to read while in school. Although it is a very renowned piece of literature. It has received its fair share of extensive and bitter criticism. Back in the nineteenth century the book was most commonly described as coarse, vulgar, irreverent, and unrefined. For every negative review there is just as many positives, and whether it’s good or bad reviews Huckleberry Finn is one of the most controversial topics between literary critics. When Twain wrote this bookRead MoreThe Article Fathers Involvement On Children s Services : Exploring Local And National Issues1421 Words   |  6 PagesThis essay will be critiquing the article ‘Fathers Involvement in Children s Services: Exploring Local and National Issues in ‘Moorlandstown’ (Gillina et al, 2012). The article uses qualitative method to establish why fathers are less likely to access children services. It will be using the critical appraisal skills programme (CASP) framework to understand qualitative research to critique this research (CASP, 2013). This framework has been chosen to aid the critical thinking in a systematic manner